I hate to reiterate what I have said in a previous post, but I also hate when people sell snake oil products which don't do anything of what they claim and make money off of people with it. Scientific research has shown with several studies that Vitamin B patches have no effect on repelling mosquitos, yet patches are still being widely sold in Canada and the US, and they aren't cheap either. Patches such as Insect Defend in Canada, and mosquito Patch in the US list Vitamin B as their main ingredient.
I tested a brand of patch out myself in Algonquin Park in June, and it didn't do sweet effée for me. By that I mean sweet F.A. By that I mean it didn't do fuck all for me. I was still completely covered with mosquitoes sinking their proboscises into my skin every couple seconds. And it makes your sweat stink to boot.
Read some more info on these links to references and you be the judge. To me this is hard evidence and it is obvious that these things do nothing to repel mosquitoes:
http://acenutrients.com/insectrepellantsmadewithvitaminb1/
http://bit.ly/19LVITx
I am glad some scientific testing has been done to prove some of these so-called mosquito repellents do not work.
Ramblings about all that's cool with hiking, paddling, outdoor photography and appreciation of the outdoors...
Showing posts with label Insect repellent. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Insect repellent. Show all posts
Tuesday, 6 August 2013
Saturday, 24 March 2012
100 Percent DEET in Canada
On the topic of DEET(N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide) insect repellent, people have widely varying opinions of the stuff. Some regard it as liquid gold, won't leave the house without it and slather it on any chance they can get, while others won't touch it with a ten foot pole and treat it like it's nuclear waste. Myself, I am mostly middle ground. I try not to use it as much as possible since it is a nasty chemical, oily on your skin and it will even dissolve some plastics. I only use it when the bugs are completely insane such as Algonquin Park in June. Luckily at least for myself, I am not affected by mosquito bites, only the pinch when they are actually biting and them buzzing around my head is annoying. I don’t even get red bumps or itchy afterwards, let alone get a much worse blister reaction as some people do get after mosquito bites. In my opinion citronella and all other ‘natural’ DEET-free repellents don’t do a thing for bug repellency and are just a scam plain and simple. Last year in Algonquin I even tried some Insect Defend brand vitamin B / thiamine patches you apply to your skin that supposedly naturally repels insects as you excrete vitamin B through perspiration, but all it did was annoyingly make my sweat smell like Alpha Bit cereal (yes seriously), and did absolutely nothing to repel mosquitos - I was still getting eaten alive like I was a piece of steak thrown to famished sled dogs after they had run the Iditerod. So that said, I certainly don’t love DEET but I will use it on occasion.
When I use it I would prefer to use the strongest stuff I can get. In preparing to go to Borneo that definitely is the case. Unlike in Canada where mosquitos don’t transfer many diseases other than West Nile, which I personally think is much overhyped, mosquitos in the tropics have the potential to transmit a whole slew of terrible diseases, some of them being incurable and don’t even have a vaccination for. Japanese encephalitis, malaria, yellow fever, dengue fever are among some of the mosquito borne diseases and can attack either day or night. Not only that, jungle leeches are repelled and can be removed with DEET. So, I would like to have the strongest DEET available for the short period of time I’m going to be in Borneo. However, Canada decided to limit DEET products for sale to 30% DEET in 2002 due to health concerns. DEET in very rare cases has the potential to cause seizures, and there is some evidence that long term exposure to the stuff can cause insomnia, irritability and other ill effects, but again I only use the stuff when needed and for short periods of time.
Luckily you can still get 100% DEET products in the US. Canada has banned the sale of higher than 30% DEET in Canada but not the importation is my understanding. So I bought a couple bottles of the Ben’s 100 (98.1% DEET) from EBay from the US – it arrived with no problems at my house. You can only get Ben’s 30 here in Canadian stores, Muskol as well only is 30% DEET. Just thought I would share this little trick if you are looking for the strong stuff and have no qualms about using it... sparingly.
Links:
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)
